Annie Campbell Updated February 22, 2019 Updated by us 2/12/21
- Most Unique Flavor: Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla. Just tastes super different from the others’ flavor. If you’re from Texas, you know Blue Bell.
- Can’t Put Down the Spoon: Breyers Natural Vanilla. Not one foul word could be said by our testers about this flavor. The carton delivered on a perfectly creamy texture and classic sweetness.
- #2: Haagen-Dazs Vanilla: Almost unanimously liked, this vanilla carton is one of the only three flavors released when the brand started, and it’s clear why it has stood the test of time. (My favorite – WCW)
- #1: Graeter’s Handcrafted French Pot Madagascar Vanilla Bean. (From Cincinnati) Behold, the hands-down champion of a tedious ice cream battle. The creamy, buttery, and perfectly sweet, this frozen treat earned it a solid five-star review. Tasters loved the super smooth consistency and delicious, complex vanilla flavor. (My favorite – K. Ship nationwide! $79.95 for 6 Pints or $119.95 for 12 Pints )
Total Page Visits: 398 - Today Page Visits: 1